Carbon Source Growth Assay

Carbon Source Growth Assay, v1.0 Kathryn E. Caruso · 0009-0003-2436-1791 Foreman Lab · Center for Biofilm Engineering, Montana State University Updated March 2026

How to cite this protocol Caruso, K.E. (2026). Carbon Source Growth Assay, v1.0. Foreman Lab, Center for Biofilm Engineering, Montana State University. https://kathryncaruso.github.io/methods/carbon-source-growth-assay/

Purpose

Growth assay to determine preferred carbon source for cold-adapted ureolytic bacterial isolates. Isolates will be grown in liquid urea-based media with different carbon sources (malate, succinate, acetate) and monitored via OD600 measurements over ~5 days.

Isolates:

Isolate Source Rationale
GG8 Gilkey Glacier Most basic of the Gilkey Glacier isolates (other than GG27B) following transfers
GG27B Gilkey Glacier Fast grower on glucose media
GNP012 Glacier National Park Has urea transporter
GNP014 Glacier National Park Has urea transporter and turned pink quickly initially

Original base media

Component Amount Notes
Yeast extract 0.1g  
Glucose 0.5g  
K2HPO4 0.3g Potassium phosphate
pH 6.8 ± 0.2 Adjust with 1 M HCl or NaOH
Urea 20g  

Experimental conditions:

Condition Carbon Source Forumla
1 Sodium DL-malate C4H4Na2O5
2 Sodium succinate C4H4Na2O4 · 6H2O
3 Sodium acetate (anhydrous, 99%) C2H3NaO2

Experimental design summary:

  • 4 isolates × 3 conditions × 3 replicates = 36 inoculated tubes
  • 3 uninoculated media blanks (1 per condition) = 3 blank tubes
  • Total: 39 tubes

Materials

Media/reagents:

  • Yeast extract
  • Sodium DL-malate, disodium salt (MW 178.05 g/mol; CAS 676-46-0) — racemic mixture; only the L-form is metabolically active as a TCA cycle intermediate
  • Sodium succinate dibasic hexahydrate (disodium succinate hexahydrate; MW 270.14 g/mol; Sigma-Aldrich Cat. No. S2378; CAS 6106-21-4) — note: hexahydrate form; account for water of crystallization in mass calculations
  • Sodium acetate, anhydrous, 99% (MW 82.03 g/mol, CAS 127-09-3)
  • K2HPO4 (potassium phosphate)
  • CH4N2O (urea)
  • 1M HCl
  • 1M NaOH
  • Sterile deionized water

Equipment:

  • Analytical balance
  • Graduated cylinders or volumetric flasks
  • Magnetic stir bar and stir plate
  • 0.22 μm syringe filter
  • Sterile syringe
  • Sterile collection bottles/flasks
  • Glass culture tubes: DurexTM Borosilicate, disposable, 16 × 150 mm (Cat. No. 47729-580) — ×39 minimum
  • Color-coded stickers for tube labeling
  • Inoculating loop (sterile)
  • Rotating shaker at 15°C (in fridge)
  • Spectrophotometer (OD600)
  • Sterile pipettes and tips
  • 70% ethanol
  • pH strips
  • Lab notebook

1 Pre-experiment preparation

Timeline

Combustion and autoclaving must be completed before media preparation day. Combustion takes several hours including cool-down.

1.1 Combust glassware

Combustion (dry heat sterilization) removes all organic residues and ensures tubes are free of contaminants that could interfere with growth or OD readings.

  1. Wrap glass culture tubes (×39 minimum + spares) loosely in aluminum foil
  2. Place in combustion oven
  3. Combust at 450°C for 5 hours
  4. Allow to cool completely inside the oven before removing — do not open door while hot (thermal shock can crack tubes)
  5. Keep tubes wrapped/covered until use

Note

Do not combust any plastic (caps, etc.)

1.2 Autoclave tube closures and other equipment

Autoclave all non-glass items that will contact sterile media or cultures.

Items to autoclave:

  • Tube caps/closures

Procedure:

  1. Wrap or bag each item loosely in aluminum foil — ensure steam can penetrate
  2. Autoclave at 121°C, 15 psi, 15–20 min dry cycle
  3. Allow to dry and cool completely inside autoclave
  4. Store sealed/wrapped until use
  5. Label autoclave tape with date and initials

Note

Disposable items that come pre-sterilized (e.g., syringe filters, pipette tips, microcentrifuge tubes, Falcon tubes) do not need to be autoclaved. The glass culture tubes are combusted (Section 1.1), not autoclaved.


2 Preparing media

Prepare 3 base media (one per carbon source condition) following the same procedure as the original urea-based growth medium protocol, substituting the carbon source as indicated.

2.1 Media formulations

Carbon source concentrations

Concentrations matched on a molar carbon basis to 0.5 g/L glucose (16.67 mmol C/L). Use the sodium salt forms of malate and succinate — biologically equivalent to the free acids but more stable and easier to handle.

Carbon Source Reagent Form Formula MW (g/mol) Carbons Mass for 16.67 mmol C/L
Glucose Free sugar C₆H₁₂O₆ 180.16 6 0.500 g/L
Malate Sodium DL-malate, disodium C₄H₄Na₂O₅ 178.05 4 0.742 g/L
Succinate Sodium succinate dibasic hexahydrate (Sigma S2378) C₄H₄Na₂O₄·6H₂O 270.14 4 1.126 g/L
Acetate Sodium acetate, anhydrous (CAS 127-09-3) C₂H₃NaO₂ 82.03 2 0.684 g/L

Calculations

Reference: Glucose at 0.5 g/L

  • 0.500 g/L ÷ 180.16 g/mol = 2.776 mmol/L
  • 2.776 mmol/L × 6 C/molecule = 16.67 mmol C/L

Malate (sodium DL-malate disodium, MW 178.05 g/mol, 4 C/molecule):

  • 16.67 mmol C/L ÷ 4 C/molecule = 4.167 mmol/L
  • 4.167 mmol/L × 178.05 g/mol = 0.742 g/L
  • Note: Reagent is a DL racemic mixture — only the L-form is expected to be metabolically active. Mass has not been doubled to compensate, as the additional osmotic load could confound results. Note as a limitation when interpreting.

Succinate (sodium succinate dibasic hexahydrate, MW 270.14 g/mol, 4 C/molecule):

  • 16.67 mmol C/L ÷ 4 C/molecule = 4.167 mmol/L
  • 4.167 mmol/L × 270.14 g/mol = 1.126 g/L
  • Note: The hexahydrate form means a large fraction of the mass is water — this is why the required mass is so high relative to the other carbon sources.

Acetate (sodium acetate anhydrous, MW 82.03 g/mol, 2 C/molecule):

  • 16.67 mmol C/L ÷ 2 C/molecule = 8.333 mmol/L
  • 8.333 mmol/L × 82.03 g/mol = 0.684 g/L

Table 1. Base medium formulation per condition (per liter). Amounts calculated to match 16.67 mmol C/L (equivalent to 0.5 g/L glucose).

Component Condition 1 (Malate) Condition 2 (Succinate) Condition 3 (Acetate)
Yeast extract 0.1 g 0.1 g 0.1 g
Carbon source Sodium DL-malate (disodium, MW 178.05 g/mol): 0.742 g Sodium succinate dibasic hexahydrate (MW 270.14 g/mol): 1.126 g Sodium acetate anhydrous (MW 82.03 g/mol): 0.684 g
K₂HPO₄ 0.3 g 0.3 g 0.3 g
Milli-Q water to 1000 mL to 1000 mL to 1000 mL
pH target 6.8 ± 0.2 6.8 ± 0.2 6.8 ± 0.2

DL-malate limitation

The malate reagent available is sodium DL-malate (racemic mixture). Only the L-form is expected to be metabolically active as a TCA cycle intermediate. The mass has been calculated based on total malate (both isomers) — effectively only ~half the carbon may be bioavailable.

2.2 Volume planning

Component Malate (200 mL) Succinate (200 mL) Acetate (200 mL)
Yeast extract 0.020 g 0.020 g 0.020 g
Carbon source 0.148 g 0.225 g 0.137 g
K₂HPO₄ 0.060 g 0.060 g 0.060 g
DI water to 200 mL to 200 mL to 200 mL

2.3 Prepare each base medium

For each of the 3 conditions, follow the base medium preparation steps from the original urea-based growth medium protocol (Sections 1.1–1.5):

  1. Weigh components
  2. Dissolve in ~80% of target Milli-Q water volume
  3. Adjust pH to 6.8 ± 0.2
  4. Bring to final volume to 200mL
  5. Autoclave at 121°C, 15 psi, 20 min/liter (liquid cycle)
  6. Cool to room temperature

2.5 Prepare urea solution

Follow the urea solution preparation from the original protocol (Section 2):

  1. Weigh 20 g urea per 100 mL DI water (20% w/v stock)
  2. Dissolve at room temperature (do not heat)
  3. Filter sterilize through 0.22 μm syringe filter in biosafety cabinet
  4. Store at 4°C; use within 1 week

2.6 Combine base medium and urea solution

For each condition, aseptically combine base medium and urea stock to achieve 2% (w/v) final urea concentration:

  • Work in biosafety cabinet
  • C1V1 = C2V2: (20%)(V₁) = (2%)(final volume)
  • V1 = 10% of final volume as urea stock
  • Remaining 90% = base medium
  • Mix gently by swirling

3 Inoculum preparation

Approach

Cultures are grown up from single colonies in R2A, OD600 is measured, and inoculum volume is adjusted for each isolate to achieve a consistent starting OD across all tubes and isolates.

3.1 Prepare starter cultures

For each of the 4 isolates:

  1. Select an individual colony from the R2A agar plate
  2. Using a sterile loop, transfer the colony into a 50 mL Falcon tube containing 10 mL sterile R2A broth
  3. Incubate on a shaking incubator at 15°C until visibly turbid

3.2 Standardize inoculum

Target starting OD: 0.025

Measuring starter culture OD

Many starter cultures will be too dense to read directly — use a cuvette dilution series:

  1. Add a small volume of starter culture to 1000 µL Milli-Q water in a cuvette
  2. Measure OD600; if reading is >0.3, try a smaller volume or re-dilute
  3. Back-calculate the true OD of the undiluted culture:
    • True OD = measured OD × (total cuvette volume ÷ sample volume added)
    • Example: 10 µL culture in 1000 µL total → True OD = measured OD × 100
  4. Repeat with additional volumes if needed to confirm; average confirmatory reads
  5. Record all dilution steps and measured values in lab notebook

Calculating inoculum volume

Use C1V1 with the confirmed true OD:

  • C1 = true OD of starter culture
  • V1 = inoculum volume to add (solve for this)
  • C2 = 0.025 (target starting OD)
  • V2 = 3000 µL (final tube volume)
  • V1 = (0.025 × 3000) ÷ C1
  • Round to nearest 5 µL for pipetting accuracy

Inoculum volumes (inoculation date: 2026-03-04)

Isolate True OD (confirmed) Inoculum volume Medium volume R2A carryover
GG8 0.863 85 µL 2915 µL ~2.8%
GG27B 0.165 455 µL 2545 µL ~15%
GNP012 1.115 65 µL 2935 µL ~2.2%
GNP014 0.956 80 µL 2920 µL ~2.7%

3.3 Inoculate experimental tubes

  1. Add the appropriate volume of starter culture to each tube, then bring to 3 mL final volume with the corresponding condition medium
  2. Leave blank tubes uninoculated
  3. Cap all tubes and record time of inoculation
  4. Measure and record actual Day 0 OD600 for each tube to confirm starting density

4 Tube labeling

4.1 Color-coded sticker scheme

Assign one sticker color per isolate for quick visual identification:

Color Isolate
Purple GG8
Blue GG27B
Green GNP012
Yellow GNP014
Orange Blanks

4.2 Full tube list

Tube # Isolate Carbon Source Replicate
1 GG27B Malate 1
2 GG27B Malate 2
3 GG27B Malate 3
4 GG27B Succinate 1
5 GG27B Succinate 2
6 GG27B Succinate 3
7 GG27B Acetate 1
8 GG27B Acetate 2
9 GG27B Acetate 3
10 GG8 Malate 1
11 GG8 Malate 2
12 GG8 Malate 3
13 GG8 Succinate 1
14 GG8 Succinate 2
15 GG8 Succinate 3
16 GG8 Acetate 1
17 GG8 Acetate 2
18 GG8 Acetate 3
19 GNP012 Malate 1
20 GNP012 Malate 2
21 GNP012 Malate 3
22 GNP012 Succinate 1
23 GNP012 Succinate 2
24 GNP012 Succinate 3
25 GNP012 Acetate 1
26 GNP012 Acetate 2
27 GNP012 Acetate 3
28 GNP014 Malate 1
29 GNP014 Malate 2
30 GNP014 Malate 3
31 GNP014 Succinate 1
32 GNP014 Succinate 2
33 GNP014 Succinate 3
34 GNP014 Acetate 1
35 GNP014 Acetate 2
36 GNP014 Acetate 3
37 Malate Blank
38 Succinate Blank
39 Acetate Blank

5 Incubation

  • Temperature: 15°C (fridge)
  • Agitation: Rotating shaker, 150RPM
  • Duration: ~5 days

6 OD600 measurements

6.1 Measurement schedule

Measurements are taken more frequently during early growth and spaced out as the experiment progresses. Days 1 and 2 each include three timepoints to capture early growth kinetics.

Day # Timepoints
0 1
1 3 (M1, M2, M3)
2 3 (M1, M2, M3)
4 1
5 1

6.2 Measurement procedure

For each measurement session (single or one of multiple timepoints in a day):

  1. Remove all tubes from the shaker
  2. Blank the spectrophotometer with the corresponding uninoculated blank for each condition — blank once per condition, before reading all tubes in that condition:
    • Blank with BLK-Mal → read all 13 malate tubes
    • Blank with BLK-Suc → read all 13 succinate tubes
    • Blank with BLK-Ace → read all 13 acetate tubes
  3. Read OD600 directly in the glass culture tubes
  4. Record the time of measurement (HH:MM) for each reading
  5. Return tubes to shaker promptly

Consistency

Use the same spectrophotometer and same tube orientation (align any seam or mark) for every reading throughout the experiment. The blanking tube for each condition should also be read consistently in the same orientation.


7 Endpoint measurements

At the conclusion of the experiment (~Day 5):

7.1 Final OD600

  • Take final OD600 reading as in Section 6.2

7.2 Endpoint pH

  • Measure pH of each tube using a pH meter (preferred) or pH strips
  • Record pH alongside the final OD600 reading
  • Compare to initial pH (6.8) — an increase toward alkaline suggests urease activity